AIMS
home
About AIMS
Research
Facilities
News
Search
Site map
Site index
Topics index



|
Status of coral reefs of the world:
1998
7B. Status of coral reefs in the northwest Pacific Ocean: Micronesia and east
Asia
Jim Maragos, Charles Birkeland and Gregor Hodgson
Abstract
The reefs vary from those in near pristine condition where there have been
few human impacts, to many that are seriously degraded and continuing to
degrade. Those reefs off the mainland of China, Japan, and Taiwan have been
damaged by sediment and pollution, and are subject to some of the heaviest
fishing pressures in the world, including blast and cyanide fishing. Reefs are
also heavily impacted by regular typhoons and plagues of crown-of-thorns
starfish, and most show major reductions in living coral cover. Few reefs have
reproductive-sized fishes. Reefs of the Marianas Archipelago have also
deteriorated in both coral cover and fish populations. By contrast, the reefs of
Palau, the Federated States of Micronesia, and the Marshall Islands are
generally in good health, with serious degradation only around population
centres where there is sediment and nutrient pollution. Fishing activity has
traditionally been light to moderate, however, there is an almost insatiable
demand from Asian and American markets for quality reef products, and fishing
pressures are increasing dramatically. Giant clams, sea cucumbers, trochus
shells, lobsters, and many of the top quality fish are being depleted on even
remote reefs, and there is increasing evidence of destructive fishing (dynamite
and cyanide). No reefs in the region are adequately managed, but reef
conservation is receiving higher priority in all countries, though the countries
use widely differing management strategies. Unless there are concerted efforts
to reduce stresses on reefs by reducing human activities and applying sound
resource management, there will be a continuing trend of reef
degradation.

Introduction
The Pacific basin has been divided into four regions with two in each essay.
These divisions are based on the culture of the peoples who settled these
islands, and geographic locality. Northeast Asia and Micronesia (northeast
tropical Pacific) are covered in this essay. The companion essay covers
Melanesia, in the southwest Pacific, and Polynesia in the east Pacific. There is
a wide range of countries, from those with massive populations like China, to
those with small populations like Palau; and from the wealthy, like Japan and
Guam, to developing countries in Micronesia.
Status of reefs in the northwest Pacific
The condition of reefs in this region range from near pristine with few human
impacts, to many reefs that are seriously degraded with pressures increasing on
them. The reefs off China have been heavily damaged by sediment runoff from
floods of the large rivers of the mainland. Fishing pressures are also amongst
the highest in the world, along with massively increasing pollution. The reefs
of Taiwan are similarly affected, but at a reduced scale, however there are
concerted efforts to conserve some of the reef resources. There has been a
decrease from 50% living coral cover to 30% during the past decade. Japanese
reefs are also chronically damaged by sediment and nutrient pollution, as well
as heavy fishing pressures. There has been a policy to line many rivers and much
of the coastline with concrete, such that reefs have been damaged directly, or
inundated rapidly with fresh water. Indeed, 19% of Japanese reefs have been
removed. The effects of a large crown-of-thorns starfish plague in the late
1960s are still seen on many reefs. Between 1972 and 19811984, there was
decrease in coral cover on 55 of 76 sites in the Ryukyu Archipelago. Reef
conservation, however, now has a much higher priority in Japan.
Reefs of the Marianas have generally deteriorated. Since 1981, about 5% of
113 sites around Guam have shown living coral cover over 50%. Coral recruitment
has significantly decreased over this time, and over-fishing has reduced the
size of fish so much that the reproductive potential of fish is only 5% of what
it once was.
The other reefs of Micronesia (Palau, Federated States of Micronesia, and the
Marshall Islands) are in much better health, with some damaged reefs around
population centres because of sediment and nutrient pollution. Local fishing
pressures are slight to moderate, however, there is clear evidence on some reefs
of destructive fishing (use of dynamite which smashes corals in a circular
area). On most reefs, there is the virtual extinction of giant clams, sea
cucumbers, trochus shells, lobsters, and many of the top quality
fish.
Natural stresses to northwest Pacific reefs
The stresses are similar to the preceding chapter with tropical typhoons
(cyclones) and long-fetch ocean waves being the major physical factors that
influence reef growth. There are on average 17.8 typhoons (or hurricanes or
major cyclones) each year in the Western Pacific Monsoon Trough, which starts in
southern Micronesia and hits places between the Philippines to the south and
Okinawa to the north. Guam is in the approximate centre of this typhoon highway,
and has been impacted every year on average by a major typhoon. These generate
heavy waves, such that the corals on these reefs are very rugged and compact,
with few large colonies in shallow water. Many of the islands in the Federated
States of Micronesia and southern Japan are gradually subsiding, simulating sea
level rise. This will compound the effects of global climate change in these
areas. Freshwater runoff with increased amounts of sediment and nutrients have
damaged the reefs around high islands, particularly in lagoons and shallow bays,
for example Pohnpei in the Federated States of Micronesia, the large islands of
Palau, Guam, and southern Japan. The crown-of-thorns starfish (Acanthaster) has
had a particularly devastating impact on the reefs of southern Japan, and many
reefs have not recovered since the outbreaks of the late
1960s.
Human stresses to northwest Pacific reefs
Human pressures on coral reefs increase towards the highly populated areas in
the west, being particularly high off Asia, and less in the Marshalls and
Kiribati. Nutrient (sewage) and sediment pollution is higher near the larger
populations, for example Japan, and Taiwan, and lower in the low islands and
atolls of the east. Pollution effects are also greatest in atoll lagoons,
particularly where circulation is sluggish, and near large towns, for example
Tarawa (Kiribati), and Majuro (Marshall Islands). Much of Micronesia suffered
major military impacts during the World War II along with coastal construction,
particularly the building of airports over coral reefs and construction of
ports. The effects of nuclear and missile testing can still be seen on some
atolls, for example Bikini, Enewetak, Kwajalein (the Marshalls) and Kanton,
Christmas, Malden (Kiribati). Stressed reefs have been unable to recover from
Acanthaster plagues in Okinawa and other Ryukyu Islands of Japan.
A rapidly increasing problem in the Pacific, particularly in the west near
Asia, is the use of destructive fishing practices, especially blast (dynamite)
fishing, poisons (cyanide, bleach) and unattended gill nets. The high demand for
fisheries products in Asia has resulted in the accelerated stripping of giant
clams, sea cucumbers, trochus, shark (for their fins), sea turtles, and coconut
crabs off many west Pacific reefs, and even more remote reefs in the Central
Pacific. The explosive demand for live reef fish for the restaurant trade in
Hong Kong and other Chinese cities has fuelled an industry based on stunning
large fish with cyanide and transporting them in tankers. This has resulted in
the local extinction of many reef fish and a trail of dead coral
reefs.
Northeast Asia
This region covers sub-tropical East Asia, to the north of Vietnam and the
Philippines, and includes China (including Hong Kong), Japan, Korea, and Taiwan.
Most of the coral reefs grow around volcanic islands, with some on the
continental shelf. The major reefs are those of Japan, which extend in an arc
from the Ryukyus, just to the east of Taiwan, north to the main islands. As
well, Japan has the Bonin Islands (a continuation of the Marianas Chain), and
the distant Marcus islands (Minami-tori Shima) 3500 km east of Taiwan. The reefs
of Taiwan are mostly fringing reefs with some platform reefs. Scattered coral
communities and some reefs occur off the southeast corner of mainland China,
including Hong Kong and islands to the north, and Hainan Dao island and the
Xisha Qundao islands to the south. There is little information for many of the
Chinese reefs, except for Hong Kong. To the south of Korea, there are some coral
communities growing on rocky islands.
Most of the coral reefs of northeast Asia are heavily exploited, due to very
high population densities and market demand for seafood. Reefs near urban
centres are over-exploited and remote reefs are also heavily fished, often with
destructive fishing methods. The pressures on these reefs and the amount of
damage that occurs will increase with dramatically increasing populations and
economic growth in East Asia. Tourism is also increasing markedly on many
tropical and subtropical islands of Japan, Taiwan, and China, and this is adding
stresses to reefs. The principal natural stresses include typhoons, occasional
tsunamis, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, Acanthaster outbreaks, water
temperature fluctuations, and occasional episodes of freshwater
flooding.
China and Hong Kong Special Administrative Region
The two types of coral reefs, fringing and offshore atolls, of the South
China Sea are very different in status and administration. Little is known of
the offshore reefs, particularly since the sovereignty of many of the Paracel
and Spratly Islands are politically disputed. These reefs are remote from land
influences, but are fished heavily and impacted by military activities.
Corals grow from the border with Vietnam, north to Xiamen (Fujian Province,
24°N), however, there are no coastal reefs north of Guangdong Province (23°N).
There are very well-developed coral reefs off southern Hainan Island (18°N). All
Chinese reefs are heavily exploited for fish and shellfish, and most have been
damaged by pollution, sedimentation, over-fishing, especially cyanide and blast
fishing. The reefs in Yalong Bay off Sanya City in Hainan are an exception and,
have been set aside as a reserve. These reefs have a high (8090%) coral cover
and diversity, and cooperation between hotel operators and the Hainan Marine
Department in 1998 resulted in good protection against illegal fishing.
Unfortunately, there are few marketable-size fish because other forms of fishing
are still allowed, but the corals are in good condition. The first Integrated
Coastal Management project in China started in 1997 (funded by UNDP), with sites
in the coral reef provinces of Guangdong, Guangxi and Hainan. These provinces
established high-level Coastal Management Committees to plan coastal development
and conserve coral reef biodiversity. The Hainan Marine Department acknowledges
the economic value of reefs and is creating a functional zonation scheme for
Sanya reefs.
The Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (SAR) was created in 1997 when
the British colony returned to China. Hong Kong reefs were first surveyed from
19901995 by consultants for the Civil Engineering Department, and then by
university teams, Reef Check, and the Agriculture and Fisheries Department. The
reefs have been badly damaged by sedimentation, sewage, and over-fishing, with
blast fishing occurring despite active police work. Most high-value edible
species are locally extinct. Many of the best reefs were severely damaged during
1994 when high Pearl River discharges resulted in upwellings, and plankton
blooms. Up to 80% of corals died below 4 m when oxygen levels dropped; there was
lower mortality in shallow water. Bleaching in 1998 has caused some mortality,
primarily of Acropora in shallow water. New marine parks were set up in
1997 to protect small parts of some of the best remaining reef areas in Mirs Bay
in the northeast, however, there are no fishing restrictions, so reef fish will
remain scarce until the rules are changed. Many artificial reefs have been built
with concrete 'reef balls', old ships, and blocks, with plans to cover a
sizeable area of muddy-bottom.
Japan
The warm Kuroshio Current ensures that coral reefs can grow from
24oN to 30oN, and large coral formations grow as far north
as 35oN, near Tokyo. Reefs in the south are flourishing fringing and patch reefs
in the Ryukyu Archipelago. These reefs have a high diversity of corals (400
species) with many endemic species. Tropical cyclones commonly batter the
coastline of southern Japan every few years, but reefs have developed either in
sheltered areas or with wave resistant structures. Crown-of-thorns starfish
infestations devastated Okinawa reefs in 1969 and have been a chronic problem
since then.
There are serious concerns about the status of Japanese reefs, with about one
third of coral species at risk of becoming locally extinct. About seven complete
reefs (19% of Japans coral area) were removed between 1981 and 1990 by dredging
and blasting to make boat harbours or breakwaters. Agricultural practices in
Japan have been particularly polluting with sediment and fertilizer nutrients.
Another harmful practice is straightening rivers and lining them with cement.
This increases water and sediment flows onto coral reefs (and also prevents
replenishment of groundwater for agriculture). The reefs off the main island of
Okinawa have very low coral cover, and did not recover after the crown-of-thorns
starfish plague in 1969, because of continual nutrient and red clay sediment
pollution. In addition fishing pressures have been high, such that sea-urchin
populations have exploded because their normal predators have been removed.
These urchins are scraping away the coral rock base of the reefs and preventing
new coral recruitment.
Living coral cover on Ryukyu coral reefs is seriously diminishing; 63% of
sites have less than 10% living coral, and only 2% have over 50% live coral
cover (Table 1). The Environment Agency of Japan noted that only 8% of reefs had
excellent coral cover. The Agency has implemented plans for greater protection
of coral reef resources and is planning a large coral reef conservation centre
in Okinawa. There are six marine protected areas with coral reefs, including
approximately 11% of the coral reef area. The World Wide Fund for Nature Japan
is investigating ways of improving land management to reduce redsoil runoff.
Local fishermen are becoming increasingly active in managing reefs and removed
81,000 crown-of-thorns starfish (28 tons) in six days during 1996.
Table 1.
The status of coral reefs in the Ryukyus (Japan), Guam, and
Taiwan measured at different times to show the status and downward trend. The
table shows the percentage of reefs that were surveyed (No. of reefs) that have
coral cover within three ranges Low (less than 25% coral cover), Medium (between
25% and 50% coral cover) and High (over 50% coral cover).
|
Country |
No. of reefs |
Year |
Low
<25% |
Medium
2550% |
High
>50% |
|
Ryukyus |
n = 84 |
1972 |
30 |
23 |
47 |
|
|
n = 224 |
19811984 |
87 |
11 |
2 |
|
|
n = 20 |
1990 |
70 |
20 |
10 |
|
Taiwan |
n = 113 |
19921995 |
50 |
27 |
23 |
|
Guam |
n = 113 |
19721990 |
78 |
16 |
6 |
Korea
There are no true coral reefs, but around the Chejudo islands (140 km south
of the Korean peninsula) there are coral communities which are particularly rich
in soft corals. Plans to protect these islands as MPAs were strongly opposed by
the fishing lobby.
Taiwan
There are extensive fringing reefs and some platform reefs around the main
island and some smaller islands. The species diversity is relatively high, with
about 300 hard coral species, 70 soft coral and gorgonian species, and 1200 fish
species. The reefs are heavily impacted by cyclones and also have been invaded
by crown-of-thorns starfish. There has been substantial damage to the reefs
during the past ten years, with living coral cover being reduced from
approximately 50% to 30% and some species of reef fish, gastropods, and
crustaceans becoming locally extinct. Destructive fishing practices (especially
dynamite), sedimentation from construction and dredging, coral collection,
sewage pollution, aquarium fish collecting, and unregulated tourist activities
have caused this damage. Reefs in the Penghu Islands (west of Taiwan on the
Tropic of Cancer) have been extensively damaged by dynamite fishing, trawling,
and sedimentation. The Lu-tao and Lan-yu reefs (southeast of Taiwan) are being
damaged by sedimentation and intense tourist activities. Reef fish populations
are very low because of aquarium fish collecting and spearfishing.
Encouragingly, the Taiwanese government and scientists are promoting
sustainable use of the coral reefs and seven coastal conservation zones have
been established by the National Park Department within the Ministry of
Interior.
Micronesia
The eight governments in the region (the Federated States of Micronesia
[FSM], Guam, Kiribati, Marshall Islands, Nauru, Northern Mariana Islands, Palau,
and Wake Island [USA],) consist of islands scattered over a large area in the
central and northwest tropical Pacific. Volcanic islands in Micronesia are
limited to the five clusters in the Caroline islands just north of the equator,
and the 20 Mariana islands further northwest. The remaining Micronesian
countries or governments consist entirely of coral islands or atolls. There are
82 atolls concentrated in the FSM, Marshall Islands, and Kiribati. Kwajalein in
the Marshalls is the worlds largest atoll lagoon. There are two large barrier
reefs: Chuuk (FSM); and the main Palau islands; with a smaller barrier reef at
Pohnpei (FSM). Uplifted coral islands are confined to the main Palau islands,
and Nauru and Banaba, west of the Gilberts. Stable sea levels or gradual
subsidence characterizes the central and eastern parts of the region, promoting
atoll reef and some barrier reef development. Stony coral diversity is high in
the west (Palau) with over 300 species present but drops off to less than 200
species in eastern Micronesia (Kosrae Island [FSM], Kiribati).
The Micronesian countries consist of five island groups: the Mariana Islands,
including Guam and the Northern Marianas; the Carolines (including Palau in the
west and the FSM); the Gilbert-Marshalls chain (including the Marshall Islands,
Wake, Nauru, and the Gilbert portion of Kiribati); and the rest of Kiribati in
the Phoenix Islands; and the Line Islands on the other side of the Date Line.
Many of the typhoons that hit east Asia are generated in the southern parts of
Micronesia and only develop into destructive storms as they move north and west
towards the Marianas and Philippines.
Federated States of Micronesia (FSM)
This has the largest population in Micronesia and second largest land and sea
area. There are four states, each with a volcanic high island cluster (Yap,
Chuuk, Pohnpei, Kosrae) surrounded by 40 atolls and low coral islands. The four
urban centres (Colonia, Chuuk Lagoon, Kolonia, and Lelu-Tofol) are the state
capitals, with Kolonia on Pohnpei as the national capital. During the past
century, FSM coral reefs suffered from soil erosion resulting from logging,
agriculture, major coastal construction (dredging and filling), military
occupation, and World War II battles. Sunken Japanese warships in Chuuk lagoon
now serve as artificial reefs, and are popular with diving tourists. Urban
pollution and coastal development continue as the major threats, along with
poaching of giant clams, sharks, trochus, and other commercial species from
remote reefs. Reef damage is most obvious around the rapidly expanding
populations on the large islands. At some sites surveyed recently in Chuuk
lagoon (and perhaps elsewhere), blast fishing has lowered coral cover.
The Community College of Micronesia on Pohnpei is a regional centre for
education, and reef research, along with the Yap Institute of Natural Science,
and there are mariculture facilities in Pohnpei and Kosrae. No reefs in the FSM
are given complete protection, but seasonal fishing limits are imposed on
trochus harvesting. Dive operators protect the shipwrecks in Chuuk lagoon, as
these are part of rapidly growing adventure tourism in all four
states.
Guam
A territory of the USA, Guam is the largest and most populous island in
Micronesia, at the southern end of the Marianas chain. Agana is the capital on
the west coast. Guam has two different structures: a high volcanic; and raised
limestone part, and has mostly fringing reefs and two barrier reefs (Apra
Harbour and Merizo Lagoon). Urban tourism, and military development have
modified much of the shoreline and reefs on the central west coast. There is
extensive military development on the northern end, and most tourism is on the
southern end. Many reefs were also damaged during the war, but have since
recovered. The University of Guam and its Marine Laboratory are the major
centres for higher education and reef research in Micronesia. Recently Guam
established several marine and coastal protected areas (Table
2).
The fringing reefs around this large island have deteriorated since the late
1970s. Corals used to recover from natural damage, such as crown-of-thorns
predation and typhoon waves within 1215 years (from 1% living coral cover to
over 60%). In the 1960s and 1970s finding over 50% living coral cover was
common; now only 7 of the 113 surveys done in the 1980s and 1990s had over 50%
living coral cover, and 78% of surveys showed less than 25% living coral cover.
The number of new coral recruits has dropped significantly since the 1970s. Over
the same time, there was a similar decrease in fish populations. Between 1985 to
1997, the total catch per unit effort decreased by 78% and also the fish do not
produce nearly as many larvae, because the size of fish have been reduced
(reproductive potential of the fish population dropped by 95% between 1984 and
1991). The major algal-grazing fishes (scarids, acanthurids, and siganids) have
been specially targeted by fishermen and the massive reduction in populations
correlate with increases in algal cover, decreases in coral recruitment, and
decreases in cover of living coral.
Another major change on Guam is the increased rates of sediment runoff, for
example the sediment flowing out of the Ugam River doubled from 1975 to 1993.
This was because of poor agriculture, and development, and also because hunters
burn large areas every year, so now sediment flow is 243 tons per acre per
year.
Table 2. Existing protected areas for oceanic island and/or adjacent
coral reefs in the northwest Pacific. Protected areas with an asterisk (*)
exclude marine areas.
NORTHEAST ASIA
CHINA HONG KONG (SAR)
Double Haven Marine Protected Area (includes Mirs Bay HK)
Cape DAguilar Marine Protected Area (HK)
Hoi Ha Wan Marine Protected Area (HK)
Sanya Coral Reef National Marine Nature Reserve (Hainan)
JAPAN
Ogasawara National Park
Iriomote National Park
Amami Islands Quasi National Park
Okinawa Beach Quasi National Park
Okinawa Old Battlefield Quasi- National Park
Kume-jima Natural Park
TAIWAN
7 coastal conservation zones
MICRONESIA
FEDERATED STATES OF MICRONESIA
Chuuk Atoll, shipwrecks historic monument
Kosrae Island
GUAM
Haputo Ecological Reserve Area
Orote Ecological Reserve Area
Guam Territorial Seashore Park
KIRIBATI
Birnie Island Wildlife Sanctuary (WS) *
Caroraina (Caroline) Atoll WS
Cook Islet Conservation Area (Kiritimati) *
Malden Island WS *
McKean Island WS *
North Tarawa Conservation Area (Tarawa)
Rawaki (Phoenix) Island WS *
Starbuck Island WS *
Vostok Island WS
MARSHALL ISLANDS
Bokaak Atoll, leased protected area
Pikaar Atoll, leased protected area
NAURU
None
PALAU
Ngerukewid Islands Wildlife Refuge
Ngerumekaol Grouper Spawning Area
Kiribati
These islands have the largest land area and maritime jurisdiction in
Micronesia. There is one raised limestone island (Banaba) and 35 additional low
coral islands and atolls in three island clusters in the far west. The 16
Gilbert or Tungaru Islands are the largest group, and home islands of the
Kiribati culture; the ten Phoenix and nine Line Islands are the two other
clusters further to the east, which were only inhabited during the last century.
Kiribati laborers were sent to these islands, and they became part of the
Republic of Kiribati in 1979, with four of the wetter islands permanently
occupied (Kanton, Kiritimati, Tabuaeran, and Teraina). There were previous
failed attempts to settle the others, although the government is again proposing
to settle some of these arid islands to relieve population pressures on the main
islands. More than half of the land is on Kiritimati (Christmas) atoll in the
northern Line Islands, and these, plus the nearby atolls of Tabuaeran and
Teraina, are targets for population resettlement.
Tropical cyclones rarely affect these islands and there are few other natural
stresses. In general, the reefs are in excellent condition, except for damage
around population centres. Some reefs, for example Tarawa, were severely damaged
or modified during World War II. Major effects now are from urban pollution and
road and causeway construction at Tarawa and several nearby atolls, resulting in
changes to current flows and pollution of lagoons. Kiritimati and Malden were
used for atmospheric nuclear testing about 40 years ago. Phosphate mining has
stripped Banaba, and guano mining during the past century has also modified many
of the arid uninhabited islands. Fishing pressure is high on reefs around the
heavily populated atolls. Plans to establish space-shuttle facilities and
tourist resorts on Kiritimati, and to settle some of the uninhabited islands,
may cause depletion of reef species and damage some reefs. Kiritimati and
several of the Phoenix Islands are wildlife reserves, and the government has
established nine marine and coastal protected areas. Small marine protected
areas are proposed for Kiritimati, Tarawa, and perhaps Caroline atoll. The
University of the South Pacific in Fiji established the Atoll Research Centre in
Tarawa as the only research and higher education facility in Kiribati.
Marshall Islands
The Republic of the Marshall Islands consists of five low coral islands and
29 atolls, with many being very large. Seven of the northern arid atolls are
uninhabited, and most of the population lives on the southern wet atolls. There
are large towns on Majuro (the capital) in the south and Kwajalein Atoll in the
centre. Population is growing very rapidly, and some of the uninhabited atolls
are targeted to reduce population pressure on the more crowded atolls. Wake
Atoll, in the far north is a US military base.
There are few natural stresses to these reefs, but several atolls (Wake,
Enewetak, Jaluit, Mili, and Kwajalein) were devastated during the last war, and
by more recent nuclear testing on Bikini and Enewetak Atolls. These reefs have
largely recovered, but the nuclear test islands are still contaminated. Urban
pollution is severe on Majuro and Kwajalein Atolls, including Ebeye Island,
probably the most crowded island in the world. The US military uses Kwajalein
and Wake Atolls for missile testing and these developments cause some reef
damage through dredging of coral sand and rock, and in-filling to create and
develop new land. Large holes excavated in the reef flat pavements of Majuro,
Bikini, and Kwajalein, were quickly recolonized by corals, showing that these
pavements were good for coral growth, if protected from waves.
The Mid-Pacific Marine Laboratory on Eniwetak Atoll was abandoned in the late
1970s and current science and higher education are provided by a small marine
science program of the College of the Marshall Islands in Majuro. The government
recently established its first two marine protected areas (Table
2).
Nauru
This is a single raised limestone island just west of the similar island of
Banaba. Both islands were mined extensively for phosphate rock for many decades,
but mining is currently active only on Nauru. Reef growth is limited to the
narrow and steep ocean faces around the cliff-like shoreline. The main human
impacts are associated with coastal construction and operations of the port
exporting the phosphate rock. There is also some spillage of oil, phosphate
dust, and some sewage pollution, but fishing is limited because the steep slopes
are fully exposed to ocean waves.
Northern Mariana Islands
These northern islands form a Commonwealth of the USA, and consist of about
20 islands and reefs, north of Guam in the northwest corner of Micronesia. The
largest islands (Saipan, Rota, and Tinian) are in the south, and consist of high
volcanic islands capped or surrounded by limestone terraces. The capital is on
Saipans west coast at Garapan. Scattered fringing reefs are common along the
main southern islands, with a barrier reef off Garapan. Elsewhere reefs are
absent or submerged, although extensive reef development occurs around Farallon
de Medinilla. Saipan was extensively bombed during World War II, but there is
little evidence of damage now to those reefs. Tourism is the main economic
activity on Saipan with more development planned on Rota. Tinian is earmarked
for future military use.
The reefs are subjected to many natural stresses, especially typhoons, heavy
prevailing seas, earthquakes, some lava flows, and colder waters on northern
reefs. Harbour and shoreline development is concentrated off Western Saipan,
with docks also on West Rota and southwest Tinian. Urban pollution,
sedimentation, some flooding, and over-fishing are stresses near populated
areas, but heavy and often destructive fishing (poisons, dynamite) occurs along
many other coasts. Farallon de Medinilla was a bombing range for many years.
Several islands declared as wildlife reserves may include marine areas, and the
reefs off Managaha Island may also be protected (Table
2).
Palau
These are a complex cluster of volcanic islands in the north and raised
limestone islands (including the 500 famous, small rock islands) in the south,
all surrounded by an extensive barrier reef. There are also two outlying atolls
(Kayangel, Ngeruangl) and one large submerged atoll-like reef (Velasco) up to 50
km north, and a raised limestone island (Angaur), five low coral islands and one
atoll (Helen) up to 600 km to the south.
There are few natural stresses on these reefs, which largely remain in
excellent condition. Several of the larger islands have been connected by
bridges and causeways (Koror, Malakal, Ngeresbeskang, and southern Babeldaob,
the largest island), that interfere with current flow. The population is
relatively small, but extensive road and coastal development is under way to
shift more population and tourism to Babeldaob, the new capital. There is
localised reef damage from this soil erosion, plus sewage pollution and solid
waste disposal around the towns, and the export of reef fish for food and
aquariums. Sport diving and tourism is growing at an alarming rate, and poorly
designed development is resulting in reef damage.
The Japanese Palao Biological Station was abandoned during World War II, and
there are plans to build a combined Japanese-American marine biological
laboratory in the capital. This will complement the existing mariculture
research centre. The government has established a marine protected area (Table
2). The Palauans had a strong culture of marine conservation and the Palau
Conservation Society is working with the government, landowners and communities
to establish additional reserves. Several seasonal harvest reserves for trochus
have been set up on the main islands.
Reef management in the region
There are quite large differences in the management strategies used by the
governments in the region. These differences reflect the different cultures and
population densities, and the different extent and status of reef resources. The
countries with the most active strategies for management are Guam, and the
Northern Marianas. The emphasis for reef conservation is increasing in Japan and
Taiwan as both the economies and conservation ethic expand. There is, however,
little interest in reef conservation in China and the other Micronesian states
of Kiribati, Federated States of Micronesia and the Marshall Islands and Palau.
These Micronesian countries still retain considerable levels of traditional
management, but this is steadily being eroded.
Actions which Need to be taken for the region
These are some suggested activities requiring cooperation among scientists
and non-scientists to achieve success:
- Better marine environmental education to stress the importance of coral
reefs and their conservation;
- Capacity building: training Pacific islanders to manage, monitor, and
educate others about coral reefs;
- Coral reef monitoring: measure baselines and trends on coral reefs to
convince decision-makers and politicians to take action;
- Establish more marine protected areas, especially on uninhabited or sparsely
inhabited islands, before population pressures damage them;
- Community-based management, so that local communities take the lead and also
collaborate with governments to manage development and control resource
exploitation on their home reefs;
- Better environmental impact assessment and research on reef restoration
especially near urban areas, and heavily-used protected areas;
- Integrated coastal management: putting all the above together and getting
all stakeholders involved;
- Population control: this is especially important for the Pacific islands,
where there is a need for considerable public awareness and education, and a
need to give power to the women;
- Developing regional centres of excellence to enhance conservation of coral
reefs.
Jim Maragos is with the Program on Environment at the East-West Center in
Hawaii, Charles Birkeland is at the University of Guam Marine Station, and
Gregor Hodgson works in the Institute for Environment and Sustainable
Development at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology.
|