AIMS
home
About AIMS
Research
Facilities
News
Search
Site map
Site index
Topics index



|
Status of coral reefs of the world:
1998
2. Status of coral reefs in the Middle East
Moustafa Fouda
Abstract
Coral reefs of the Middle East vary considerably from the well-developed,
highly biodiverse, and near-pristine reefs of the Red Sea, to the shallow
fringing reefs in high sediment areas of the Arabian Gulf. Between these are
reefs heavily impacted by cool upwellings in the Arabian Sea. Middle East reefs
are little influenced by runoff from the land, but experience large variations
in salinity and temperature. The major human impacts come mostly from the oil
and tourism industries, although increasing urban development on the coasts is
damaging reefs through dredging and pollution. There is little active coral reef
management in the region, although several large projects are developing
national management capacity, and targeting particularly valuable tracts of
reefs.

Introduction
This region contains Middle East countries which border the Red Sea (Egypt,
Eritrea, Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, and Yemen); those which border the
Gulf of Aden and the Arabian Sea (Djibouti, Oman, Somalia, and Yemen); and those
on the Arabian (Persian) Gulf (Bahrain, Iran, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and
the United Arab Emirates).
This area is very dry, with large seasonal fluctuations in air and water
temperatures, and has probably the greatest extremes in tropical marine
climates. The reef animals and plants have been selected to survive under these
conditions of high stress. As a result of the low rainfall in the region, few
reefs are regularly affected by chronic sedimentation from the land. Near the
mouths of drainage channels (wadis), there are often breaks in the reefs or
coral communities, because flood-waters and sediment prevent reef
development.
The Red Sea and the Arabian Gulf are the most saline seas that are linked
directly to oceans, because of high evaporation and low volumes of freshwater
input. The Arabian Gulf is shallow with a constricted entrance at the Straits of
Hormuz. It has large variations in salinity (4070 ppt). In the Red Sea,
salinity averages 36 ppt near the Indian Ocean, to more than 40 ppt in the
north. Few coral species can live in areas of very high salinity.
The Arabian Gulf (1000 km by 200300 km) slopes from the shallow Saudi
Arabian side to Iran, 80100 m deep. The Gulf emptied during the last ice age,
about 12,000 years ago, so species that occur there recruited through the narrow
Straits of Hormuz. Coral reefs grow in offshore, clear waters near Kuwait and
Saudi Arabia in the Gulf. Some fringing reefs have developed at a few sites near
the shore, but are generally not well developed due to extreme variations in
temperature and light. The rest of the area consists of mud or sand, with some
dense seagrass beds.
The Red Sea is a deep (maximum depth 2850 m), flooded rift valley (2000 km by
180360 km). Coral reefs grow on the continental shelf, which is narrow (1530
km) in the north and wide (120 km) in the south. The two arms of the northern
Red Sea (Gulf of Suez, 255 km by 1445 km; Gulf of Aqaba, 180 km by 1625 km)
both have luxurious fringing reefs.
Much of the coastline of the Gulf of Aden, Arabian Sea, and Gulf of Oman is
sandy or rocky. Coral communities often develop on rocks, but are limited by
cold intense seasonal upwellings.
There are few major natural stresses on these reefs as tropical storms do not
penetrate into the enclosed waterways, and runoff from the land is minimal.
There have been outbreaks of the crown-of-thorns starfish on Red Sea and Gulf of
Oman reefs. On rare occasions, there are extreme low tides (e.g. Gulf of Aqaba)
which kill reef flat corals. Many of the human threats to Middle East reefs are
shared throughout the region, but are at different levels of intensity,
depending on the growth of coastal populations: pollution from towns and
industries; oil exploitation and transport; mining and quarrying; and huge power
and desalination plants. Increasing quantities of solid waste are being dumped
from ships and the land. Reef tourism is expanding with damage from curio
collecting and anchors in marine protected areas. Oil pollution, from
operational spills and discharge of dirty ballast water, is a continuing threat
in the Arabian Gulf and Gulf of Oman.
Middle East reefs provide increasing economic benefits to the people of the
region, which can be sustainable, if successfully managed. However, systematic
and coordinated efforts to manage these resources are being hampered by the
complex politics in this region, weak legal and environmental policy capacity,
weak administrations, poor organization, and limited skilled human
resources.
The first workshop of the International Coral Reef Initiative (ICRI) in the
Philippines in 1995 was attended by only three Middle East states, and by only
six states at the Regional ICRI Workshop at Aqaba in 1997. Many countries have
received technical and financial help from donor countries, and international
organizations, to strengthen their capacity for sustainable management of coral
reefs.
Status of coral reefs
Bahrain
The 33 low islands of Bahrain are mostly old limestone with corals (31
species; 19 genera) growing around them. The slopes are gentle with loosely
attached corals and little true reef growth. Coral cover is generally less than
10%. The reefs are used by a few traditional fishers, and for recreation. The
main human impacts arise from the dumping of dredged sediments, land
reclamation, and from oil pollution. The Directorate of Environmental Affairs in
the Ministry of Health, and the Bahrain Petroleum Company, are responsible for
marine environmental conservation and oil spill contingency plans, but few reef
areas are actively protected.
Djibouti
There are a few fringing reefs around several small islands, and some patch
reefs in the Gulf of Tadjoura, Gulf of Aden. Little is known of these reefs,
although 80 coral species occur on Musha and Maskali reefs. Impacts are
primarily from over-fishing, collection of corals and shells, spearfishing,
dredging, anchor damage, boat traffic, and resulting turbidity. There is some
tourism, and Maskali and Musha Islands are marine reserves with prohibitions on
collecting. There is no active reef management yet. The government has started
an integrated coastal management project, including the reefs, with assistance
from the Global Environment Facility and the World Bank.
Egypt
The Egyptian Red Sea coast is 1840 km long with extensive fringing reefs
facing the Gulf of Aqaba, Gulf of Suez, and the Red Sea. About 205 stony coral
species and about 120 soft coral species have been recorded for the Red Sea. The
Suez Canal area has about 45 coral species, including some endemic species.
Coral cover around northern Red Sea islands is 6080%, with 2025% on exposed
fore-reef slopes, and in some places soft corals (80%) dominate. Coral cover
along the Gulf of Aqaba ranges from 11% to 63%, with higher cover in the
south.
The coral reefs are in very good condition, with the only threats being from
fishing and tourism. Destructive fishing does not occur, but a few reefs are
over-fished, resulting in large numbers of sea-urchins. Tourism results in some
curio collection, spearfishing, and anchor damage from dive boats. At one
tourist site, coral coverage was 60% only eight years ago, but is now 27%, with
anchor damage increasing from 2% to 30%. There have been several oil spills with
no significant damage. The reefs are coming under increased management from the
Nature Conservation Sector of the Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency. Areas
include the well-known Ras Mohammed Marine National Park (1983) on the Sinai
Peninsula, and the Gebel Elba Conservation Area (1986) around the Egypt-Sudan
border. Three more parks have been declared recently (Nabq, Taba and Abu
Gallum), and two more (Red Sea Islands and Hammata) are proposed for
protection.
Eritrea
Reefs on the 1216 km coast of Eritrea in the southern Red Sea are primarily
around the Dahlak Archipelago and islands near the coast, many of which are
themselves fossil reefs. Reef development occurs usually as thin coral veneers
on other substrates, with more developed reefs around the outer islands near the
centre of the Red Sea. There is little information on coral abundance and
diversity, although surveys have been conducted by the former Ministry of Marine
Resources (MMR). The Dahlak Islands are recommended for conservation in an
integrated coastal management project in progress with funding from the Global
Environment Facility and the World Bank.
Iran
The few reefs that occur on the 2000 km coastline of Iran are near the
Arabian Sea, and around islands in the Straits of Hormuz. Most of the bottom has
soft sediments with a few corals. Information is lacking, with Shidvar Wildlife
Refuge the only existing protected area that includes areas of reef. The Iranian
National Centre for Oceanography conducted a survey of Irans coral resources
during 1998 to assist with national conservation and planning efforts, but the
results have yet to be published.
Israel
The short coastline of Israel (14 km) in the Gulf of Aqaba (Eilat) has
fringing reefs except near the ports. The reefs are well studied with 99 coral
species in 40 genera, and are in relatively good condition, although affected by
heavy tourism development. Coral cover on these reefs dropped significantly to
about 5% after extreme low tides and oil pollution, but recovered to near 40% in
some areas, although not in other areas near the sources of oil and phosphate
pollution (still at 15%). The Eilat Coral Reserve (established in 1964) is well
managed by the Nature Reserves Authority, which promotes reef
conservation.
Jordan
The 27 km coastline of Jordan is similar to the coastline of Israel. There is
a discontinuous series of fringing reefs with a narrow reef flat, less than 150
m wide, and a very shallow lagoon and back-reef. The reef front drops rapidly to
several hundred meters. Port construction has replaced much reef area, and now
tourism development is causing damage through solid waste and sewage pollution.
The Aqaba Marine Nature Reserve is not actively managed, but is legally
protected. Destructive fishing is illegal, and coral collecting and spearfishing
are forbidden. The area is the focus of the proposed Red Sea Marine Peace
Park.
Kuwait
Kuwait has very limited reef growth, not exceeding 4 km2. Isolated
corals grow on rocky outcrops, and there are some reefs around offshore cays.
All reefs are shallow (to 15 m) with about 33 coral and 100 fish species. Oil
pollution and sedimentation cause the largest impacts, and many reefs were
impacted during the Gulf War, with some long-term effects of oil pollution.
Sewage, outbreaks of sea-urchins, and damage from anchors are other problems.
There are no marine protected areas, although some islands are recommended for
protection.
Oman
The 2092 km coast of Oman has some coral reef development in four regions:
the Musandam Peninsula, which separates the Arabian Gulf from the Gulf of Oman;
rocky shores and islands near Muscat; the sheltered western shores of Masirah
Island and Barr Al Hickman; and sheltered bays of Dhofar and the Al-Halaniyat
Islands. There are 91coral species in 54 genera, with about 200 reef fish
species. Coral cover drops from 75% to 40% below 10 m, and decreases to 10%
below 15 m. Where suitable substrates occur outside these areas, there are
communities of scattered corals with live coral cover approaching 10% in places.
The major stresses are dramatic temperature fluctuations (ranging from
18oC to 34oC, with a mean of 27oC, and daily
fluctuations of 810oC during summer), and crown-of-thorns starfish.
Others include infrequent episodic rain, coral bleaching and cancer, black and
white diseases, and oil pollution. Tourism is generally not destructive, except
for some littering, curio collection and spearfishing. Most physical damage to
corals is from fishing gear, particularly nets. Coral bleaching was observed in
Acropora and some brain corals. Environmental impact assessments are
required for coastal development, and laws prohibit destructive fishing, and
protect threatened species. A management plan is being implemented for the
Daymaniat Islands, which were declared a marine protected area.
Qatar
High salinity, temperature extremes, and shallow waters limit reef growth
around the 560 km long Qatar peninsular in the Arabian Gulf. Reefs are best
developed in the east, but are shallow and low in diversity. There is little
fishing or tourism, so the major threats are oil, solid waste and sewage
pollution, and impacts from coastal developments. Living marine resources are
legally protected.
Saudi Arabia
Reefs occur on the 2510 km long Red Sea and Arabian Gulf coasts. The Red Sea
coast has extensive fringing reefs on steep slopes, with 194 coral species in 70
genera, and 450 fish species. Most reefs are in excellent condition with only
local tourism and limited artisanal fishing, but there are virtually no fishing
regulations. Other impacts come from sediment from industrial and urban
development, land filling and coastal engineering, with some chemical pollution.
The Farasan Islands and Umm Al-Qamari Island are marine protected areas, and
moratoriums on development have been approved for another 46 sites.
The Gulf coast has gentle slopes with vast shallow areas of sandy and muddy
bottoms, thus there are few reefs. There is more development on the Gulf coast
than on the Red Sea coast, with greater impacts from waste disposal, dredging,
altered water circulation, pollution, and overfishing. The reefs were damaged by
oil and soot during the Gulf War, but are recovering. There is one marine
protected area (Jubail Marine Wildlife Sanctuary).
Somalia
There are excellent, highly biodiverse, fringing and patch reefs along the
Gulf of Aden coast of Somalia, with a mix of Indian Ocean, Red Sea and Arabian
Sea species. These reefs suffer few natural disturbances and have a high coral
cover (more than 90% in places) from the reef flat down to 8 m. There is some
shark fishing on the Gulf of Aden coast, but this has had little impact on the
reefs. There are no plans for reef protection, but IUCN is working with local
administrators, donors, and other NGOs, to monitor fisheries and establish a
protected area in the Saad ed Din Islands. There are also reefs near the Kenyan
border, but the area is inaccessible, and little is known about the reefs or the
threats to them.
Sudan
Much of the 750 km Red Sea coast is bordered by fringing reefs. In the
shallow water near the coast, the reefs are from 1 km to 3 km wide. These are
separated by a wide deep channel from barrier and platform reefs, 114 km wide.
The sea floor then drops to hundreds of meters. These are amongst the richest
reefs in the Red Sea, with a high diversity of species, for example 71 coral
species occur on Sanganeb and Wingate Reefs. There are also dugong and sea
turtles.
There is little fishing on Sudan reefs. Limited tourism results in local
damage from anchors, waste disposal, and spearfishing. There is some pollution
from shipping and land reclamation near Port Sudan. There is one marine park
(Sanganeb Atoll Marine National Park), however, management and enforcement are
not strong. Sudan is planning to work with Egypt to establish the Gebel Elba
Conservation Area.
United Arab Emirates
Many bank and patch reefs, with less than 10% coral cover, grow in shallow
water around offshore islands along the 550 km Gulf coast. There is some
recreational diving but little fishing, and little is known about these reefs or
their conservation.
Yemen
The 500 km of Red Sea coast is shallow, with high turbidity and soft
sediments that limit coral growth but favour seagrass beds. About 25% of this
shore has fringing reefs or coral communities, with some better developed reefs
in the north. But diversity and coral cover (12%) are low.
The Arabian Sea coast has some areas of mixed coral and algal communities
with low live coral cover. There are several islands with low diversity fringing
and patch reefs (Aden, Mukulla, Bir Ali and Belhaf). Traditional fishing and
minimal tourism cause little damage. Destructive fishing and illegal discharge
of waste are banned, although sewage pollution may reach damaging levels around
coastal towns. Yemen has proposed four areas as marine protected areas,
including parts of the Socotra Archipelago.
Marine protection and management
There is often overlap among institutions responsible for coastal management,
and there are also ambiguous laws and regulations in most countries. Enforcement
is generally lacking, with the exception of well-managed marine protected areas
in Egypt, Israel and Jordan, where fishing and tourism are closely regulated.
Most other marine protected areas are paper parks.
In the Middle East there are regional conservation plans, supported by the
Global Environmental Facility of the World Bank, for Djibouti, Egypt, Eritrea,
and Yemen. In addition, the Marine Environmental Initiative Plan and Red Sea
Marine Peace Park for the Gulf of Aqaba, the Kuwait Action Plan (The Arabian
Gulf, Gulf of Oman, and the Arabian Sea), and the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden
Action Plan, all focus attention on problems facing coral reefs. A Strategic
Action Program (SAP), focusing on coral reef conservation, was initiated in 1995
by the Regional Organization for the Conservation of the Environment of the Red
Sea and Gulf of Aden (PERSGA), with support from countries of the region, the
Global Environment Facility, and donors like the Islamic Development
Bank.
Recommendations for management
In Middle East countries, there is insufficient research and monitoring, with
the possible exception of Israel. This situation could be assisted by
establishing networks within compatible countries to standardise methods,
implement necessary capacity building, coordinate management, and integrate
programmes to raise awareness. Improved monitoring of oil pollution, sharing of
detection skills and clean-up mechanisms, will benefit many Middle East
countries. These activities and conservation measures will require funding from
the oil and tourism industries, and from external agencies and governments with
strategic interests in the region. The strong political tensions in the region
have hindered a regional approach to coastal management, and this continues,
with difficulties in getting better representation at International Coral Reef
Initiative meetings.
Moustafa Fouda heads the Department of Fisheries Science & Technology at
Sultan Qaboos University, Sultanate of Oman. Other advice was obtained from Rod
Salm, IUCN Nairobi and Simon Wilson from the Ministry of Regional Municipalities
and Environment in Oman.
|