Contents
Introduction
Presentations
Discussions
Research
goals
Recommendations
Group
members
Discussion
list
Bibliography

AIMS home
About AIMS
Research
Facilities
News
Search
Site map
Site index
Topics index
|
Australian
Coral Records Research Group
Auscore 2000
workshop
Members of AUSCORE met for the 3rd
Annual AUSCORE Workshop in February 2000. The Workshop was
hosted by the Research School of Earth Sciences, Australian
National University, Canberra. The group discussed past and
future research plans. The following abstracts give an
indication of the range of research into coral records covered
by the group. The 4th Annual AUSCORE Workshop is
planned to be held in Brisbane in February 2001. For more
information about our research activities contact individual
authors see also profiles of our members.
ABSTRACTS
TRACE
ELEMENTS IN A PORITES CORAL FROM PANDORA REEF, GREAT
BARRIER REEF
ALIBERT
Chantal, McCULLOCH Malcolm, FALLON Stewart and KINSLEY Les.
RSES,
Australian National University, Canberra ACT 0200
Chantal.Alibert@anu.edu.au
In-shore corals of the Great Barrier Reef
are particularly exposed to extreme environmental changes
related to terrestrial inputs. Increased water turbidity from
river plumes carrying fine suspended sediments or from
resuspension of bottom sediments (e.g. along the track of
tropical cyclones), transient low salinity episodes (heavy
rainfall and freshwater plumes) or enhanced warming of coastal
waters such as during Feb 98, are some examples of the
potentially stressful events that these corals experience
during their lifetime.
Two major markers of terrestrial inputs
with contrasted geochemical behavior: Ba and Mn have been
measured using laser ablation ICP-MS in the skeleton of a Porites
coral from Pandora Reef, located near Townsville at ~15 km
from shore and ~150 km to the North of the mouth of the
Burdekin River. This record covers the recent period 1998-89
including the 91 and 98 major flood events in the wake
of tropical cyclones "Joy" and "Sid",
respectively. The accuracy and robustness of a range of
geochemical tracers (Sr/Ca, B/Ca, U/Ca, Mg/Ca. Mn/Ca and Ba/Ca)
are assessed against well-documented SSTs, rainfall, river
discharge and salinity data. Interannual and seasonal changes
of the coral extension rate are estimated from the timescale
ascribed to the Sr/Ca record by fitting to instrumental
surface water temperatures. For this Pandora coral, Sr/Ca and
B/Ca appear as the best proxy thermometers. Ba/Ca is distinct
from the other ratios as it does not show seasonal variations
but well-defined peaks associated with the fresh water plumes
of the Burdekin River deflected northward along the shore by
currents. The timing and intensity of the coral Ba peaks are
compared with the residence time of river plumes in the
vicinity of Pandora Reef, river flow and minimum salinity
figures provided by a recent study at AIMS.
LUMINESCENT
RECORDS IN CORAL SKELETONS
BARNES,
D.J. & TAYLOR, R.B.
Australian
Institute of Marine Science, PMB 3, Mail Centre, Townsville
Qld 4810.
d.barnes@aims.gov.au
Holes and indentations pushed into
laboratory grade calcium carbonate powder showed a yellow
luminescence indistinguishable from luminescence seen in coral
skeletal slices. Observations and measurements of
luminescence in hole pushed into laboratory grade calcium
carbonate powder reproduced all the features of luminescence
in coral skeletal slices. Long wavelength ultraviolet (UV)
light from fluorescent tubes and other sources used to display
coral luminescent banding and lines contains significant
amounts of violet and blue visible light. Luminescence in
coral skeletons is excited by wavelengths from UV through to
green. Light returning from holes and indentations in coral
skeletons will have undergone more reflections than light
returning from cut skeletal surface. Each reflection increases
the probability of absorption of UV, violet and blue light and
its re-emission at longer wavelengths (luminescence). Thus
light returning from holes and indentations in coral skeletal
slices will contain relatively less violet and blue visible
light than light returning from sawn surfaces of the slice.
Thus, light returned from surfaces appears blue while light
returned from holes and indentations appears yellow.
The yellow luminescence seen in slices of
coral skeletons and the blue luminescence measured in such
slices are properties of mineral calcium carbonate. In corals,
enhanced luminescence is associated with regions with larger
numbers of holes and indentations. The luminescent lines
associated with monsoonal river flows in corals from the Great
Barrier Reef are narrow regions of lower density skeleton
i.e., regions with greater amounts of holes and indentations.
These narrow, low-density regions presumably result because
significantly lower salinities reduce coral calcification
without concomitant reduction in skeletal extension. Offshore
corals, not subject to regular, periodically lowered
salinities show luminescent banding in which higher
luminescence is associated with the lower density portion of
the annual skeletal density banding pattern.
Records associated with skeletal stable
isotopes and trace skeletal inclusions are usually obtained
from the surface of a coral skeletal slice. Luminescence is a
representation of skeletal density at the surface of a
skeletal slice rather than density averaged over the thickness
of a slice, as is obtained with conventional measurement
techniques such as X-radiography and gamma densitometry. Thus,
luminescence offers a means to directly align these different
records.
INTRA-ANNUAL
VARIATION IN THE EXTENSION RATE IN MASSIVE PORITES
BARNES,
D.J., LOUGH, J.M. & TAYLOR. R.B.
Australian
Institute of Marine Science, PMB 3, Mail Centre,
Townsville Qld 4810.
d.barnes@aims.gov.au
We report measurements of the intra-annual
variation in extension rate in colonies of Porites. These
measurements were made by comparing the annual temperature
signal recorded in coral skeletons as d18O
ratios with the actual temperature signals.
Although the theoretical relationship
between temperature and d18O ratios in
skeletal carbonates is not linear, the relationship is
generally considered linear over the temperature ranges
experienced by corals. Changes in the constants used to
describe the linear relationship do not affect results given
here. The annual seawater temperature signal was assumed to be
a sine curve as a function of time. This was converted to a
temperature signal as a function of distance along a coral
slice using the relationship distance = time + constant *
sin(2*time). Thus, when the constant = 0 there were no
intra-annual variations in extension rate (distance µ
time). Where constant = 1 the coral momentarily stopped
growing in midwinter. This modified sine curve for temperature
was fitted to the isotopic data and the constant varied until
the best least squares fit was obtained. In the tropics, the
annual seawater temperature signal is not a sine curve.
Consequently, we modified the temperature signal using the
relationship above but with distance replaced by temperature
until we obtained the best least squares fit between actual
temperatures and our modified sine curve temperatures. This
provided two constants, 1 for fits of modified temperature to
isotope data and the other for fits of actual temperatures to
modified temperatures. The difference between these two
constants is a measure of intra-annual variation in extension.
Data for isotopic ratios was provided by Dr
Mike Gagan and came from a colony of Porites lutea
from Pandora Reef in the central Great Barrier Reef and
represented the period 1977-84 (see Gagan et al., 1994). The
theoretical relation between distance along the coral growth
axis and the isotopic ratio can be calculated and the
important parameter is the intra-annual change in extension
rate (Barnes et. al, 1995). Results given here are not
dependent upon the amount of thickening applied to vertical
skeletal elements. The same results would be obtained if all
skeletal growth occurred as extension. The results for three
cases are provided (Fig. 1). Fits between isotope rations and
the modified sine curve temperature data were obtained for the
entire data set and also for selected regions. Figure 2 gives
the best fit for constant intra-annual extension rate and the
best fit obtained by varying extension rate. The fitted period
corresponds to early autumn to late spring. The period over
summer was excluded to avoid rainfall effects on isotope
ratios (eg, Fig 3 see Gagan et. al., 1994). Figure 2 shows the
better fit is obtained with a variable extension rate. The
entire data set also shows a significantly better fit for a
variable extension rate (Fig. 3).
Fits made as in Figure 2 indicate about a
3-fold variation in extension rate (max extension rate /
minimum extension rate ~3). The fit for the entire data set
(Fig. 3) gave a value of 2. A lower value for the fit for the
entire data set was expected because of the two years in which
isotopic ratios peaked well above expected values, which
correspond to high rainfall years (Gagan et al., 1994). When
allowance was made for the non-sinusoidal temperature curve
(i.e. by subtracting the constants; see above), fits made as
in Figure 2 returned a 2.5-fold variation in extension rate.
It appears that this colony of P. lutea averaged growth
that was 2.5 times faster in summer than winter over the
period 1977-84.
References
1. Barnes, D.J., Taylor, R.B., & Lough,
J.M.,1995. On the inclusion of trace materials into massive
coral skeletons. Part II: distortions in skeletal records of
annual climate cycles due to growth processes. J. Exp. Mar.
Biol. Ecol., Vol.194 pp.251-275.2. 3. Gagan, M.K., Chivas,
A.R. and Isdale, P.J., 1994. High resolution isotopic records
from corals using ocean temperature and mass spawning
chronometers. Earth and Planetary Sci. Let., 121 , pp.
549-558.4.
Figure Captions
1. Theoretical relationship between the
isotopic ratio and distance along the coral. a) constant
extension, b) max. ext. rate/min. ext. rate = 2, c) coral just
stops growing in mid winter.2. 3. Best theoretical fit to part
of the data. a) constant extension, b) extension rate (
variable V) adjusted to give best fit 4. 5. Best theoretical
fit for all the data. a) constant extension, b) extension rate
adjusted to give best fit.
Porites
corals record higher trace element concentrations during
increased sedimentation, Misima Island, PNG
FALLON,
Stewart1, McCULLOCH, Malcolm1, BARNES,
David2, LOUGH, Janice2
1Research
School of Earth Sciences, The Australian National University,
Canberra, ACT
2Australian Institute of Marine Science,
Townsville, Qld.
Stewart.Fallon@anu.edu.au
In 1989 open pit gold mining commenced on
the island of Misima in Papua New Guinea. Open pit mining by
its nature causes a significant increase in sedimentation,
both natural and mining-induced. This increased sedimentation
affected the nearby fringing coral reef to varying degrees,
causing coral mortality (complete suffocation) in some areas.
This sediment consists of soft mine waste which is made up of
quartz feldspar, greenstone and schist. These rocks have
distinct chemical constituents (rare earth elements [REE],
zinc and lead etc.), that are entering the near-shore
environment in considerably higher than normal concentrations.
In this study we evaluate whether Porites corals can be
utilized as a tool for recording environmental input of trace
elements in near-shore environments.
Density, extension and calcification was
examined by Barnes and Lough (1999) for these Porites
coral colonies, they suggest that high sedimentation may not
be recorded by these growth characteristics. However, they did
note a positive correlation between decreasing coral tissue
layer thickness and proximity to the highest sedimentation
areas. This is consistent with corals under stress (Barnes and
Lough, 1992). Using laser ablation inductively coupled plasma
mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) we analyzed four colonies (2
from high sedimentation, 2 control sites) for uranium, cerium
(REE), zinc, manganese, lead and barium. The two
"severely" affected corals show low steady
"background" levels prior to the commencement of
mining. After 1989 they show dramatic increases of cerium,
zinc, manganese and to some degree lead. The control sites,
which are distal from the mining operations, do not show
similar increases in these elements after mining. In
conclusion, trace element studies of Misima Island corals
clearly record the dramatic changes in the environmental
conditions at this site and provide a basis to test the subtle
anthropogenic influences on corals in the GBR.
References
Barnes, DJ, Lough, JM (1992) Systematic
variations in the depth of skeleton occupied by coral tissue
in massive colonies of Porites from the Great Barrier
Reef. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 139:113-128.
Barnes, DJ, Lough, JM (1999) Porites
growth characteristics in a changed environment: Misima
Island, Papua New Guinea. Coral Reefs 18:213-218.
POSTER
HIGH
RESOLUTION ENVIRONMENTAL RECORDS FROM THE GREAT BARRIER REEF
(GBR): A TRACE ELEMENT STUDY OF PORITES CORALS AND CORALLINE
SPONGES
FALLON
Stewart, McCULLOCH Malcolm, MARSHALL John, ALIBERT Chantal
Research
School of Earth Sciences, The Australian National University,
Canberra, ACT
Stewart.Fallon@anu.edu.au
The rapid high-resolution analytical
technique of Laser Ablation ICP-MS is used to measure boron,
magnesium, strontium, barium, and uranium abundance in Porites
corals and coralline sponges. Cores from Porites
sp. coral colonies were collected from inshore, mid-shelf and
outer reef localities (central GBR) to test the robustness of
these elements as environmental proxies. The inshore reefs
selected for this study are heavily influenced by river runoff
whereas the mid-reef and outer-reef locations are not. This is
clearly recorded by Ba/Ca, which provides an excellent proxy
for river run-off. Time series analyses of Sr/Ca, U/Ca, B/Ca
and Mg/Ca are compared to in-situ sea surface temperature
(SST) and/or IGOSS NMC weekly SST to provide calibrations for
these elements. Previous workers have noted differences in the
calibration of Sr/Ca vs. SST; this LA-ICP-MS data-set shows a
slight variation between different corals, although the TIMS
Sr/Ca is highly reproducible. This suggest small scale
intra-coral variability. Both the U/Ca and Mg/Ca have
calibrations within error for mid-shelf and outer reef corals
but the calibrations differ for the inshore corals. The B/Ca
appears to be more robust in terms of its temperature
calibration.
Recently, coralline sponges have been
proposed as a new source of tropical paleoclimatic
information. Profiles of d13C in coralline
sponges have documented (better and more accurately than
corals) the atmospheric increase of d13C
associated with increased fossil fuel consumption. Sponges
were collected from 2 locations on the outer GBR, Ribbon Reef
#10 and Myrmidon Reef. Preliminary results suggest these
sponges will provide meaningful proxy information about past
conditions in the same manner as corals. Due to their very
slow growth rates (~0.2 mm/yr) sponges are better suited to
recording and providing long-term environmental information.
When samples are compared at longer-term (annual to several
years), patterns appear which are consistent between Sr/Ca,
Mg/Ca, B/Ca and Ba/Ca. U/Ca appears to vary both in and out of
phase with respect to the other three elements. The B, Mg and
Ba concentrations are 2-5 times lower than in corals with
concentrations of ~20 ppm, ~200 ppm and ~4 ppm, respectively.
The Sr and U concentration are 1-2.5 times higher than in
corals with concentrations of ~9000 ppm and ~8 ppm,
respectively.
ENVIRONMENTAL
CONTROLS ON GROWTH IN PORITES
LOUGH,
J.M., BARNES, D.J.
Australian
Institute of Marine Science, PMB 3, Townsville MC. Qld
4810
j.lough@aims.gov.au
Annual extension, density and calcification
were measured in 245 similar-sized colonies of Porites
from similar locations on 29 reefs from across the length and
breadth of the Great Barrier Reef (GBR). Average growth
characteristics were obtained for an eight-year period common
to all colonies. Extension rate and calcification rate
decreased from north to south along the GBR (latitudinal range
~9o) and were significantly and directly related to
annual average sea surface temperature (SST; range 25-27oC).
For each 1oC rise in SST, average annual
calcification increased by 0.39 g.cm-2.yr-1
and average annual extension increased by 3.1 mm/yr. Density
was inversely correlated with extension rate and increased
with distance from shore. Data for massive Porites
colonies from the GBR were extended through 20o of
latitude and an average annual SST range of 23-29oC
using published data for the Hawaiian Archipelgo (Grigg, 1981)
and Phuket, Thailand (Scoffin et al., 1992). The response of
calcification rate to SST remained linear. Variation in annual
average SST accounted for 84% of the variance. For each 1oC
rise in SST, average annual calcification increased by 0.33
g.cm-2..yr-1 and average annual
extension by 3.1 mm.yr-1. Annual minimum SSTs were
more closely related to calcification and extension rates than
annual maximum SSTs. Inter-annual variations of calcification
in Porites were previously reported (Lough &
Barnes, 1998) to be about half as sensitive to variations in
SST. These data are shown, however, to closely match the
linear fit based on 44 Indo-Pacific sites. Thus, variation in
calcification rate of Porites with average annual SST
appears to be similar whether examined over space or time. The
sensitivity of calcification rate in Porites to SST,
combined with observed 20th century increases in
SSTs, suggests that calcification rates may have already
significantly increased along the GBR in response to global
climate change.
PROXY
SEA SURFACE TEMPERATURES FROM 7600-8000 YEAR BP CORALS FROM
MYRMIDON REEF, CENTRAL GREAT BARRIER REEF
MARSHALL
John, BURROWS Daryl and McCULLOCH Malcolm.
Research
School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University,
Canberra, ACT
John.Marshall@anu.edu.au
Four Porites sp. corals, with U/Th
ages of 7600-8000 years BP, were recovered from the base of a
drill hole on the windward margin of Myrmidon Reef. Sr/Ca
ratios have been measured for each coral by isotope dilution
thermal ionisation mass spectrometry. These ratios have been
converted to sea surface temperature (SST) by using the
calibration of a modern Porites sp. with a 10 year
instrumental record from the same reef (Sr/Ca.103 =
10.40 - 0.0575T). Two corals show SSTs that are about the
same as modern values, but one coral shows SSTs that are
1.5-2.0°C warmer than present and another 1-2°C
cooler. Two of the corals show distinct cooling trends which
resemble an El Nino signal in modern corals from the region.
The difference in SSTs for these chronologically similar
corals could be related to some not being sampled along the
major growth axis.
An unusual feature of these corals is that
they show fluorescent bands, which is normally associated with
river runoff events in near-shore corals. The modern Myrmidon
corals do not show fluorescence. Also, there is the presence
of distinct Ba/Ca peaks, as measured by laser ablation ICP-MS.
Again, in near-shore corals these anomalies have been
interpreted as runoff events. However, the distance from
Myrmidon Reef to the coast of over 100 km precludes any effect
of river runoff, even at 8000 years BP when sea level was some
20 m lower than present. This is confirmed by the d18O
signal which, when corrected for sea level, matches the Sr/Ca
curve. The fluorescence and Ba/Ca anomalies suggest that
upwelling along the edge of the shelf was more prevalent than
it is today.
While the Sr/Ca data suggests that SSTs
were similar to the present day, the d18O-derived
SSTs, calibrated against an inshore coral, are cooler by
2-3°C. The lower SST range is more consistent with Sr/Ca-derived
SSTs in corals of similar age from the Huon Peninsula and
Vanuatu. However, it is considered that the Sr/Ca derived SSTs
are more reliable because of their calibration with
instrumental and modern coral data from the same reef.
RESPONSE
OF PORITES CORAL AT FRANKLANDS ISLANDS AND PANDORA
REEFS TO RIVER RUN-OFF AND MASS-BLEACHING EVENTS
McCULLOCH M1.,
S. FALLON1, C. ALIBERT1, L. KINSLEY1
and M. DEVLIN2.
1Research
School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University,
Canberra, ACT
2Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority,
Townsville, Qld 4810. Australia.
Malcolm.McCulloch@anu.edu.au
The inshore region of the Great Barrier
Reef is subject to the combined stresses of terrestrial
run-off from flood plumes as well as unusually warm SSTs
that can induce coral bleaching. In February-March 1998, as
part of a global phenomenon, the inner GBR experienced an
episode of large-scale mass coral bleaching that was probably
the most intense and widespread yet recorded. More than two
thirds of the inshore reefs exhibited high-levels of bleaching
with a quarter being subject to extreme (irreversible?)
bleaching (Berkelmans and Oliver, Coral Reefs 18, 55-60,
1999). Immediately prior to this event, incursion of low
salinity flood plumes occurred in the inshore region of the
central GBR as a result of a monsoonal depression. To better
quantify the response of Porites coral to both river
run-off and possible impacts on coral bleaching, we report
here high-resolution laser ablation and mass spectrometric
trace element analyses of Porites coral from the
inshore Frankland Island and Pandora Reefs.
Trace element proxies for sea surface
temperature (Sr/Ca, U/Ca and Mg/Ca) and river run-off (Ba/Ca,
Ce,/Ca, Y/Ca) were determined in corals collected 8 months
after the mass bleaching episode from the inshore reefs at
Frankland Islands and Pandora Reef. All the corals clearly
record the high temperature bleaching event, indicating that
calcification continued despite SSTs being in the range of
30-31oC. For 2-4 weeks following the bleaching
episode, some growth (extension) of the coral polyps
continued, although at a much lower density, indicating a
major decrease in the overall rate of calcification,
presumably due to the expulsion of symbiotic algae. This
latter phase is recorded as a rapid increase in both the Sr/Ca
and U/Ca ratios. During the bleaching event, corals also show
anonymously high Mg/Ca, another possible fingerprint for
bleaching. The longer-term response to the bleaching is
variable. One coral shows relatively minor effects,
corresponding to an ~1 month hiatus in calcification. Another
coral still containing tissue, remains dormant after 8 months,
showing no signs of renewed calcification. Finally there are
many dead Porites where macro-algae has resorbed parts
of the former coral tissue.
In early January 1998, the flood plumes
that entered the inner GBR from the Russell-Mulgrave and
Burdekin Rivers impacted corals at Frankland Islands and
Pandora Reefs respectively. The timing and approximate
magnitude of the flood peaks is faithfully recorded in the Ba/Ca
ratios in corals from these localities. In river systems Ba is
strongly particle reactive, only undergoing desorption as it
enters the estuarine zone. Thereafter, Ba probably undergoes
approximately conservative mixing, although this remains to be
established for the GBR over a wide salinity range. The
self-consistent records from the Frankland Islands and Pandora
Reefs appear to substantiate this inference and implies that
Ba/Ca ratios in corals may provide a proxy for riverine
suspended sediment loads being delivered to the inshore GBR
(Sinclair and McCulloch, 2000). Bleaching in the inshore GBR
may have been exacerbated by the formation of a relatively
stable low salinity lid that promoted rapid warming of
shallow waters. Studies are using long-lived (400-500 year
old) Porites corals may thus provide a better
understanding of possible links between flood plumes and
severe episodes of coral bleaching.
DIGITAL IMAGE
ANALYSIS OF CORAL UV FLUORESCENT BANDING
McGREGOR, Helen1,
HAY, Stuart2, SINCLAIR, Daniel1
1Research
School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University,
Canberra, ACT 0200
2Photography, The Faculties, Australian National
University, Canberra, ACT 0200
helen.mcgregor@anu.edu.au
At present, the conventional way of
measuring coral UV fluorescence in Australia involves the use
of a fluorometer (Fluorac) at the Australian Institute of
Marine Science. As an alternative to Fluorac digital image
analysis (DIA) of coral UV fluorescence has been developed.
With the DIA technique, the grey level of a digital image of
coral fluorescence is an indirect measure of fluorescence. DIA
is a cheap alternative to measuring UV fluorescence on a
fluorometer and, if set up correctly, will facilitate fast
acquisition of fluorescence data.
The digital image of the coral UV
fluorescence is obtained by photographing the coral using
conventional methods, then scanning the image into a computer.
Initially markers, used to define the image scale, are placed
on an ultrasonically cleaned 7mm thick coral slice. The coral
slice is illuminated under two UV tubes and black and white
photographs are taken. A yellow filter is used to cut out the
blue part of the spectrum. Focus shifting, aperture, exposure
times and the placement of the coral in the photograph are set
to increase image clarity and to minimise any potential lens
edge distortion effects. A standard piece of coral is also
placed in the same position in each photograph so that the
photos can be calibrated. Finally, coral photographs are
scanned into a computer with scanning parameters set to
minimise possible changes to the image brightness and contrast
during the scanning process.
Coral image grey levels are measured using
NIH Image v 1.61 software available free from the Internet at http://rsb.info.nih.gov/nih-image/download.html
. Changes in
grey level on the image represent the changes in intensity of
the fluorescent banding. These changes are measured along a
user-defined sample path and the image grey levels are
calibrated and the scale set in the NIH Image program.
To date, visual comparison of the image
grey level with coral fluorescence is favourable. There are
however, some changes in image contrast induced by the
scanning software and testing is under way to remove these
changes. The final stage in the development of this procedure
will be to compare results from DIA with those from Fluorac,
(ensuring that the same data processing methods are used), and
comparing these datasets with river discharge data. Corals
from Pandora Reef, Queensland and Blup Blup Island, Papua New
Guinea will be used for the comparitive study. Reproducability
of coral UV fluorescence will also be investigated, along with
changes in Sepik River discharge, using two corals from the
same site at Muschu Island, Papua New Guinea.
POSTER
VARIABILITY OF d13C,
d18O AND Sr/Ca RATIOS IN NINGALOO REEF
CORALS (WESTERN AUSTRALIA) - LINKS TO ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS
MULLER, Anne,
GAGAN, Michael K., McCULLOCH, Malcolm
Department of Geology
and Research School of Earth Sciences, Australian National
University, Canberra, ACT 0200
amuller@geology.anu.edu.au
Massive coral such as the genus Porites
are increasingly used as climate proxies in the tropics where
instrumental data is insufficient or lacking. More work is
underway to extend the methods used such as
measuring ?d13C, d18O and Sr/Ca ratios.
The objective of this paper is to monitor coral response to
changes in environmental parameters in Ningaloo Reef and to
show the reproducibility of results from 5-year increments
over 150 years before pursuing high resolution work for
selected time spans. The importance of a careful petrographic
and mineralogical investigation of coral cores prior to
geochemical analysis is stressed, because small
post-depositional alteration of the coral skeleton appear to
cause significant shifts in the geochemical signal and mask
environmental signals. We also show that a multi-proxy
approach can considerably increase confidence in the
interpretation of geochemical data from massive coral.
Two long coral cores of Porites lutea
from Ningaloo Reef, covering time periods of 168 and 140 years
have been investigated. Stable isotopes of carbon
(d13C) and oxygen (d18O) have been measured on
5-year increments of these cores to demonstrate the
reproducibility of 150-year trends and to determine the
magnitude and reproducibility of interdecadal variability for
both coral colonies. Sr/Ca ratios have been measured for every
second 5-year increment to allow differentiation between
temperature and salinity signals of the d18O-record.
The ?18O values in both cores
suggest very stable sea surface temperatures (SST) over the
last 100 years. However, the cores show different magnitudes
of the d18O suggesting that the values are not
controlled by SST alone. The differences between the Sr/Ca and
d18O curves, the residual
d18O signals
(Dd18O), suggest the presence of different
salinity regimes at the sampling sites. High residuals
coincide with high SST in the core taken west of North West
Cape, suggesting enhanced evaporation associated with
enrichment of 18O in seawater in a lagoonal enviroment. In the
bottom part of the second core taken north of North West Cape,
secondary aragonite is present, the geochemical data shows the
strongest anomalies, and there is good correlation between d18O,
d13C and Sr/Ca ratios. The magnitude of
variation in these ratios suggest a strong imprint from a
secondary precipitation of aragonite, obscuring any
temperature signal.
STUDYING
REGULAR DISTORTIONS TO TRACE ELEMENT SST CYCLES
SINCLAIR,
Daniel J.
Research
School of Earth Sciences, The Australian National University,
Canberra ACT 0200
dan.sinclair@anu.edu.au
Modern analytical methods such as
laser-ablation ICP-MS allow coral skeletons to be
simultaneously analysed for a number of chemical tracers. At
the RSES it is common to analyse a suite of elements including
B, Mg, Sr, Ba, U, Y, La, Ce, Mn, Zn, and P. Typically B/Ca,
Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca, and U/Ca vary seasonally in Porites corals,
apparently linked to cycles in SST. These 4 trace elements do
not correlate exactly with each other in corals, however. It
therefore appears as if other chemical or biological factors
can influence each trace element independently, producing
subtly different variations on a straight SST profile. As more
corals are analysed, patterns are beginning to emerge which
may give clues as to what chemical or biological factors
influence trace element signals.
As an example, a regular -ve spike
occurring during mid summer destroys the usually strong
seasonal cycle in Mg/Ca profiles in a number of corals. A
similar phenomenon occurs in U/Ca profiles, although the
magnitude of the distortion relative to the amplitude of the
seasonal signal appears to be less than in the Mg/Ca signal.
One interpretation of this observation is that Mg and U
respond independently to two environmental parameters. SST
variations give rise to a seasonal signal, which is countered
by an unknown parameter for which Mg is more sensitive than U.
In this presentation, I will give examples
of trace element signals that deviate from a seasonal SST
cycle. I will also explore a number of hypothetical models,
and discuss how this research might proceed in the future.
CALCIFICATION
IN SOFT CORALS (ALCYONACEA)
TENTORI,
Ernestina
Central
Queensland University, Rockhampton QLD 4702
e.tentori@cqu.edu.au
Alcyonacean corals are formed by tissues,
mesoglea and sclerites. Their colonial, benthic growth is
associated with their use of secondary metabolites in the
competition for space amongst other problems of life in coral
reefs. Other biological attributes, still not fully studied,
allow them to occupy areas beyond the distribution boundaries
of scleractinian corals. The sclerites make up to 36% of the
colony volume fraction. Like other biomineral structures,
sclerites are a potential reservoir of enviromental
information. Before using them as indicators, we need to
answer these questions: How fast are soft coral sclerites
formed? Is calcification affected by environmental parameters?
What is the life-span of soft coral sclerites? Is
calcification coupled with cellular growth in soft corals?
Experimental work addressing these questions and carried out
after the first AUSCORE meeting is summarized here.
-
Not all regions of the soft coral colony calcify at the
same rate. The base of the colony has a significantly
higher calcification rate than the top of the colony as
measured by 45Ca labelling of sclerites of Litophyton
arboreum. Cellular growth rates follow a similar
pattern, however, both measurements have not been
performed simultaneously yet and it is not known if both
processes are coupled.
-
Calcification is sensitive to light but not in the same
fashion as observed in scleractinian corals. Soft corals
demineralize in the absence of light as shown by
preliminary experiments on Sinularia sp. using the
alkalinity anomaly technique.
-
Mg/Ca ratios show significant variations between
sclerites obtained in winter and summer times. During
winter, the Mg/Ca ratio is lower than during summer. These
measurements were made on Sinularia and Dendronephthya
collected in the fringing reefs of Keppel Bay, GBR. These
variations seem to be associated with light intensity
and/or water temperature. Mg/Ca ratios performed on
sclerites from Sinularia, Anthelia, Sarcophyton,
Litophyton collected through autumn, winter and summer
time at the aquarium of the Museum of Oceanography of
Monaco did not show significant variation. This aquarium
is kept under constant temperature, salinity and light
regimes.
-
All sclerites are surrounded by living cells. Most of
the sclerites are located in the mesoglea. These
observations have been made by TEM on Sarcophyton
sp.
A model of calcification in soft corals and
their potential as bio-indicators will be discussed.
|