Climate change and the tropical marine environment
Coral reefs and mangrove forests contribute greatly to tropical coastal productivity and provide habitat for myriad fish and other species. These important ecosystems are under unprecedented pressure around the World due to declining water quality, overexploitation, and climate change. Australia has some of the healthiest coral reefs on the planet due to our low population density and strong environmental management with the best known systems being the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) in Queensland and the Ningaloo Reef Tract in Western Australia. Corals thrive in locations which also happen to be near their physiological limits, making them sensitive to stresses caused by sea temperature anomalies resulting in the phenomenon known as coral bleaching. Corals are also potentially threatened by increasing ocean acidity linked to rising carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere, which impairs the ability of calcifying organisms to build their skeletons.
AIMS contributes to understanding the implications of a changing climate by monitoring, reconstructing and modelling the changing ocean climate, assessing impacts of climate change on coral reef and other organisms, identifying potential adaptation mechanisms, and identifying characteristics and locations that may provide refuges for marine species in a rapidly changing world.
What we know
- Atmospheric levels of CO2, the main greenhouse gas, measured from many locations around the world have been rising steadily for decades and the rate of increase is accelerating. This includes measurements taken for CSIRO Gaslab from the AIMS headquarters site at Cape Ferguson in North Queensland where the level of atmospheric CO2 has risen from 355 parts per million (ppm) in 1992 to 385 ppm in 2009, a steady increase of approximately 1.7 ppm per year and consistent with the 40% increase since the late 18th century (World Data Centre for Greenhouse Gases)
- The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere is known to be increasing and about 30% of the extra CO2 dissolves into the ocean. As a consequence of this CO2 absorption the chemistry of the oceans is changing and becoming more acidic.
- A growing body of experimental evidence is showing that seawater acidified to mimic potential future scenarios significantly impacts upon the health of some fish and coral species. There are many millions of species in the ocean and each will have different sensitivities to acidification and respond in different ways. No single species lives in isolation and how the effects seen at an individual species level translate to an ecosystem response is not yet fully understood. It is likely that acidified seawater will alter the makeup of marine ecosystems (as recently demonstrated by AIMS' research in a naturally high CO2 environment) and weaken coral reef structures.
- The long-term average surface water temperature of the Great Barrier Reef has increased by about 0.5oC since the 19th century and the Reef system has experienced two mass coral bleaching events (1998 and 2002) caused by long periods of coral exposure to unusually warm seawater. Significant coral bleaching was observed in early 2011, due to thermal stress, on Ningaloo Reef, WA.
- Warming waters along Australian tropical coastal regions have already resulted in southward shifts in climate zones, especially obvious in northern Tasmania.
- Sea surface temperatures have been increasing over the past century and climate models predict a continuation of this trend. The full implications for coral reefs need more research and monitoring but it is highly likely that the makeup of ecosystems will change. It seems likely that reefs will continue to exist . They are likely, however, to suffer a loss of diversity and changes in community composition. We are also likely to see shifts in species to different parts of reefs, depending on their adaptation or otherwise to the changing conditions.
- During the 1998 coral bleaching event, 42 per cent of shallow water coral reefs on the GBR bleached, and an estimated 2 per cent died that year. This equates to approximately 400 km2 of reef area.
- In 2002, the largest bleaching event on record, an even greater proportion of the Reef bleached (55 per cent) and an estimated 5 per cent died. This equates to approximately 1000 km2 of reef area
- While these percentages may seem small, more frequent disturbances will increasingly compromise our coral reef ecosystems.
- Coral bleaching was again observed in the 2006 summer in the southern GBR, where local water temperatures reached around 1-2oC above the seasonal average.
- Coral reefs may take 10 to 20 years to recover from serious bleaching events that can cause coral death or sublethal effects that result in reduced growth and no breeding for one to two years after.
- It is known that heat stress causes corals to expel the symbiotic algae they host in their tissues. What is not sufficiently understood are the numerous mechanisms that may enable corals to adapt to new, warmer and potentially more acidic conditions.
- Coral reef ecosystems are dependent upon microbial interactions with each other and with their hosts, such as the central relationship between coral and its symbiotic algae and bacteria. Microbes are centrally involved in the physical processes concerned with phenomena such as the carbon cycle, where they convert CO2 into nutrients.
- Tropical cyclones are an occasional source of physical disturbance to coral reefs [report from TC Hamish]and although tropical cyclones may not become more frequent, when they do occur in a warmer world they are likely to be more intense.
- The El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the major source of inter-annual variability in tropical climate and has a major influence on Australian weather with drier conditions across northern Australia in El Niño years and wetter conditions during La Niña events. How ENSO frequency and intensity may change in a warming world is still unclear but any change would have significant impacts for Australia.
- Potential changes to ocean currents and circulation patterns are also likely and there is already evidence that the East Australian Current is strengthening and penetrating further south. Such changes will affect reef connectivity, which, for example, influences sources of larvae on reefs. Precise projections are not available yet.
- More extreme rainfall and river flows have been predicted and may lead to greater flows of freshwater and terrestrial runoff into reef systems. Recent evidence from proxy climate records in coral cores from the GBR suggest this is already happening.
- In a paper published in April 2011 in the prestigious scientific journal Paleoceanography, AIMS latest research indicates that tropical rainfall has already become more variable which is consistent with a warming world, with extreme wet and dry events occurring more often. Using AIMS' coral cores, Australia's most comprehensive library of coral cores from long-lived Porites corals, researchers were able to reconstruct northeast Queensland summer rainfall back to the late 17th century, providing over 300 years of records to examine past climate variability and change. View more on this topic
- Even without changes in total rainfall, warmer air temperatures (as already observed for Australia) will enhance the intensity of drought conditions. This may have the secondary effect where loss of vegetation due to the drought may lead to increased terrestrial run-off when droughts break. Declining water quality from drought-breaking floods can reduce coral diversity and increase seaweed cover on inshore reefs.
- Global sea level has already risen ~ 20 cm since the late 19th century and is observed to be rising around Australia's coast.
- Ecosystems operate in a complicated environment and while there is a growing body of data about how marine organisms respond to warmer seawater temperature, and increased acidity, far less is known about how these organisms will function and respond when both of these parameters change.
- Of key concern for sustaining our valuable tropical marine ecosystems is the current rapid (and accelerating) rates of change in their environment. We need to understand the capability of marine organisms and ecosystems to successfully respond and adapt.
AIMS carries out research that underpins current understanding of how a changing climate associated with global warming and increased acidity of the ocean may affect coral reef ecosystems.
AIMS bases its assessment of current conditions and likely future scenarios on verifiable data gained in the field, from a range of laboratory-based experiments, and from its unrivalled collection of coral cores dating back hundreds of years.
The consequences of increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide
The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere has risen to the current level of (2011) 394 parts per million (ppm) from about 270 ppm before the Industrial Revolution started in the mid-18th century. Measurements of atmospheric CO2 taken from AIMS headquarters outside Townsville agree with this global figure (see page 1 of this document).
Under current IPCC projections and assuming no measures are adopted to reduce CO2 emissions, atmospheric CO2 concentrations are likely to reach 500 -750 ppm in the second half of this century. If that is the case, global temperature averages may increase at least by 2oC and possibly more.
Coral reefsfigure prominently in our national identity. The GBR contributes more than $5 billion annually to the Australian economy. Ningaloo Reef in WA is growing in economic and environmental importance, as are the Kimberley Coast and Oceanic Shoals off WA's northwest. While Australia's coral reefs are well managed, they are not isolated from global atmospheric and ocean changes.
Coral bleaching is not a new phenomenon – the coral animal is sensitive to a variety of stresses and bleaching is a natural response. Since the first recorded global mass coral bleaching episode in 1998, which was caused by unprecedented thermal stress, the phenomenon has been under intense scientific scrutiny.
The stress induced by higher temperatures causes a breakdown in the fundamental relationship that is at the heart of all coral reefs: the mutually beneficial relationship between the coral animal and its symbiotic algae, the zooxanthellae. The fragile equilibrium of this relationship operates within a finely-tuned sea surface temperature range.
A key question is whether corals can enter into new symbioses with more temperature-tolerant zooxanthellae, without losing some other benefits from their symbiotic association. Some zooxanthellae are more tolerant of higher temperatures than others, but they may not allow corals to grow as fast as they would with their usual symbionts. Another key question is whether southward migration of larvae of the more warm water adapted northern corals will be fast enough to ameliorate population losses from warming.
Ocean acidification is a recognized consequence of increasing atmospheric CO2 (the main greenhouse gas). About 30% of the extra CO2 from the atmosphere has so far dissolved in the oceans, causing their alkaline/acid balance (their "pH") to shift more towards acidic. The oceans have been efficiently absorbing a large proportion of that extra atmospheric carbon – in fact, if they had not done so we would have experienced more global warming than we have already. Oceans are naturally slightly alkaline and this is conducive to the calcifying process at the heart of tropical coral reefs.
If projections are correct that pH could decrease by up to 0.4 pH units by the end of this century, this would be well outside the realms of anything organisms have experienced over many millions of years. While 0.4 pH units might not seem like a lot, because pH is measured on a negative log scale this equates to a 2.5-fold increase in the concentration of hydrogen ions.
Coral reefs are built from the carbonate skeletons of corals. Corals are calcifying organisms – they take dissolved material from the surrounding sea water to grow their calcium carbonate skeleton. Corals are not alone in doing this – many marine plants and animals build calcareous crusts, skeletons or shells, contributing to reef growth. This process is linked to the pH of seawater. As seawater heads down the pH scale to become slightly more acidic, the growth (calcification) of many coral species is likely to be increasingly compromised. Scientists are still determining what this will mean for coral reef ecosystems and the multitude of organisms that live in and on reefs and other tropical marine environments.
Many processes depend upon the pH of the surrounding environment being within a certain range to function properly. These include deposition of marine cements to enable benthic organisms to attach to surfaces, or fertilisation of eggs by sperm which may affect the number of larvae produced by organisms that release their gametes into the ocean.
Absorption of CO2 by seawater will not only result in changes to seawater pH, it also changes the composition of the dissolved gases available for animals to breathe through their gills. Absorbing more CO2 into their bodies may have an effect on their health and behaviour and may alter the pH of their body fluids.
Possible reef responses to climate change
Physiological acclimatisation and/or genetic adaptation are needed for corals to cope with higher temperatures and more acidic oceans. If the current rate of climate change continues, corals will have to acclimatise or adapt within the next few decades rather than over millennia. Whether corals can adapt quickly enough to cope with climate change is a subject of much research. Are corals able to pass genes on to their offspring to enable them to tolerate higher temperatures in a short time span? With conditions changing rapidly, their capacity to do this within only a few generations may be crucial.
AIMS is examining whether and how the community of algae within corals might "shuffle" to become dominated by more heat-tolerant strains. This phenomenon was first observed by AIMS scientists in corals from the Keppel Islands group after the 2006 bleaching event and is being extensively investigated at present. Corals in the waters around the Keppel Islands now have a much higher proportion of two more thermally tolerant strains of symbiotic algae than they did before the bleaching event, and are better able to cope with higher sea surface temperatures. However, this is just one species at one location and it is not known yet whether this can be extrapolated to the rest of the Great Barrier Reef or to other reef systems.
The combined effects of seawater warming and acidification are only now starting to be studied. Ideally such studies may be done at naturally occurring sites that exhibit conditions akin to those forecast for future oceans. This includes organisms that live naturally in warm and acidic environments such as those found around undersea volcanic CO2 vents.
In May 2011, a scientific paper was published in the prestigious, international scientific journal Nature Climate Change outlining results of an AIMS-led research expedition to one of these natural sites occurring in Milne Bay, Papua New Guinea. It is the only known, cool CO2 seep site in tropical waters containing coral reef ecosystems. The research showed the number and types of corals making up coral reefs are much reduced, the closer they are to the natural CO2 seeps. Diversity of corals drops by 40 per cent and the reef becomes dominated by one form of corals, massive Porites. The natural CO2 seeps have given scientists rare insights into what tropical coral reefs could look like, if human-induced atmospheric CO2 concentrations continue to rise unabated. View more on this topic.
Controlled experiments in laboratories are also essential to assess causality. The range of marine species that can be experimentally investigated in the laboratory is, however, a tiny fraction of the number of species that live in the ocean.
AIMS research on climate change
While supporting moves to reduce CO2 emissions globally, and making significant cuts to AIMS' own energy consumption, the Institute is investing in research to understand the significance of climate change for tropical marine ecosystems including the Great Barrier Reef.
AIMS scientists have monitored decadal changes in coral cover on reefs of the GBR using two methods. The first involves divers estimating coral cover around the whole perimeters of reefs using manta tows and has been used to survey coral on many reefs along and across the GBR since the mid-eighties. Secondly, coral communities have been studied more intensively in marked sites on the NE slopes of 47 reefs using photographic methods. A recent analysis of manta tow data from 1985-2004 showed that coral cover fluctuated in an unsynchronised manner in different subregions of the GBR but the mean value of coral cover for all reefs declined by 0.21% per year over this period (Sweatman et al. 2011). Analysis of coral cover on the fixed photographic sites showed average declines of 0.27% per year over 15 years between 1995 and 2009 (Osborne et al. 2011). While the two rates of coral loss are similar, the greater number of reefs that were sampled over a longer time by manta tows meant that the loss of coral cover estimated by this method was statistically different from zero change, while the net loss of cover estimated by the photographic methods on intensive survey sites has not yet reached statistical significance. However the gross result disguises a significant decline over time of the non-acroporids corals, which recover more slowly after disturbance than the fast growing Acropora species.
In Western Australia, AIMS has also monitored since 1993 the status and trends of fish and coral populations on Scott Reef (just over 400km northwest of Broome in the Indian Ocean). In 1998, when mass bleaching was observed on 70 per cent of reef systems worldwide, severe bleaching conditions killed more than 80 per cent of the corals on Scott Reef. Ongoing monitoring shows that coral and fish communities are still recovering from this major disturbance.
AIMS' monitoring of the physical ocean environment through satellite observations and moored oceanographic instruments has shown that most coral bleaching is caused by a combination of high light and heat stress (i.e. seawater that is warmer than the average seasonal cycle).
Q-IMOS is a geographic node of the Australian Integrated Marine Observing System (IMOS – www.imos.org.au) managed by AIMS on behalf of a number of partners.Q-IMOS is an observation network that seeks to understand the influence of the Coral Sea on continental shelf ecosystems in Queensland including the GBR Marine Park. In the next decade, Q-IMOS will monitor the effect of rising ocean temperatures on the incidence of coral bleaching, and on the frequency of regional upwelling that fuels productivity in sections of the GBR. In the longer term, Q-IMOS will monitor the impact of global climate change upon ocean chemistry that threatens the survival of calcifying organisms, such as coral.
Q-IMOS consists of a number of sub-systems that together provide a picture of the main ocean features and the impact these have on coastal marine systems with a focus on coral reefs.
The core sub-system is an array of moorings located at key locations along the reef to detect and monitor the impact of ocean circulation events on coastal waters especially the movement of off-shore water onto the Great Barrier Reef such as during upwelling events. It also monitors the main current system, the East Australia Current (EAC) that flows down the eastern Australian seaboard as well as looking at how changes in ocean patterns are linked to changes in primary ocean productivity.
The mooring array is supported by an enhanced satellite observation system that collects daily images from a range of satellites showing patterns of surface temperature, ocean productivity and coastal runoff.
At the reef-scale, seven reefs are being intensively monitored using innovative wireless sensor network technology that gives real time data about water movement and ecosystem health at the bommie or even coral head scale. These networks link into the larger scale mooring arrays and satellite imagery to allow ocean phenomena to be tracked down to the scale of sections of the reef through the mooring array and then down to individual reefs and even reef areas through the wireless sensor networks.
This linkages across scales will allow, for the first time, a better understanding of how large scale changes in the oceans, such as seen in El Nino and La Nina events, impact down to individual corals and how these corals, in response, adapt and sustain themselves.
An understanding of how the oceans impact the coast and real-time observations of basic parameters such as temperature and salinity can allow scientists to better understand events such as coral bleaching and, through rigorous aquarium and laboratory testing by AIMS scientists, allows for the development of an index of bleaching risk based on cumulative heat stress (degree-heating days), making possible the forecast of major bleaching events. The linking of observation systems and models opens up new possibilities in forecasting events such as coral bleaching and the impact of events such as tropical cyclones.
About a quarter of AIMS' research effort is now directed at marine microbes and symbiosis using advanced genetic and molecular approaches. This reflects the importance of microbial life to all major biogeochemical cycles and disease. The symbioses of sponges, giant clams and corals all involve specialised microbes; and all of these symbioses are disrupted by sudden variations in sea temperatures. More detailed studies of coral symbiosis have shown that one species of coral can host multiple genetic strains of the photosynthetic zooxanthellae symbionts and that different combinations have highly varied heat tolerance. More heat tolerant combinations trade off better survival in warmer water with slower colony growth under average conditions, raising the possibility that reef-building corals can persist in a warming ocean through selection for more heat-tolerant symbioses. Answers to this crucial question are being pursued through a combination of controlled experiments in aquaria and reciprocal transplant experiments in natural populations to assess the viability of different symbioses in different thermal environments.
Theoretical models of coral bleaching have been developed that implicate water quality as an extra factor modifying bleaching risk. The models predict that higher levels of dissolved nitrogen in the environment will raise the risk of bleaching for any given combination of light and temperature. This important idea requires testing through controlled experiments and, if supported, will provide a strong rationale for the current attempts to halt and reverse the decline of water quality in coastal seas caused by terrestrial runoff from agricultural landscapes.
At the ocean boundary, some locations experience the upwelling of deep water to the surface. These intrusive waters have the potential to both raise and lower the risk of coral bleaching because they contain higher levels of key dissolved nutrients but are also colder coming from deeper levels. The trade off between these influences seems likely to explain some of the spatial variations in bleaching among offshore reefs during seasons of heightened risk. To incorporate such variations, AIMS and CSIRO are building the most accurate three-dimensional model of water circulation yet developed for the continental shelf of Queensland. Once validated, this model will be used to forecast regional risk for different parts of the GBR under different climate scenarios downscaled from Global Climate Models.
AIMS scientists recently detected a decline in calcification rates by massive corals on the GBR during the past two decades that is unprecedented in at least, the past 400 years. The reduction in growth rates are likely due to the increased frequency of thermal stress events, potentially worsened by progressive ocean acidification. Controlled experiments are, however, required to establish the cause of this decline in the rate of calcification.
National Sea Simulator
AIMS' ability to conduct the required experiments will be boosted by new resources approved in the 2009-10 Commonwealth Budget. Recognising the importance of climate change in the marine environment, the Australian Government has provided $35 million for the construction of an advanced experimental seawater facility at AIMS' headquarters in Townsville. This large facility will provide controlled environment spaces and will be available to external scientists by application. The ability to manipulate multiple factors (temperature, salinity, nutrients and pH) independently in complex experimental designs will allow scientists to test the responses of marine organisms to the range of hypothetical environments anticipated from different degrees of climate change and to predict the future for marine systems under various climate scenarios.
AIMS is also increasing its investment in monitoring natural marine systems across tropical northern Australia. This has been made possible by new investments by the Commonwealth and Queensland Governments in integrated marine observing systems (http://imos.org.au/). This will include the first direct monitoring of carbonate saturation levels in complex reef systems to understand how water chemistry cycles affect reef construction rates by calcareous organisms.
New knowledge on the impact of climate change on the marine environment and process understanding will inform a new generation of spatial and process models predicting areas of relative risks and vulnerabilities from climate change that will in turn inform decision making by natural resource managers, policy formulation and the exploration of potential mitigation strategies.
It will also assist in providing refuge strategies for sensitive marine species in a rapidly changing environment.
- Alongi DM (2008) Mangrove forests: resilience, protection from tsunamis, and responses to global climate change. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science 76: 1-13.
- Berkelmans RWC, De'ath AG, Kininmonth SJ Skirving WJ (2004) A comparison of the 1998 and 2002 coral bleaching events on the Great Barrier Reef: spatial correlation patterns, and predictions. Coral Reefs 23: 74-83
- De'ath AG, Lough JM and Fabricius KE (2009) Declining coral calcification on the Great Barrier Reef. Science 323: 116-119.
- Fabricius KE (2008) Theme section on "Ocean Acidification and Coral Reefs". Coral Reefs 27: 455-457.
- Veron JEN (2008) Mass extinctions and ocean acidification: biological constraints on geological dilemmas. Coral Reefs 27: 459-472.
- Fabricius KE, Hoegh-Guldberg O, Johnson J, McCook L and Lough J (2007) Vulnerability of coral reefs of the Great Barrier Reef to climate change. Pp 515–554 in: Climate Change and the Great Barrier Reef, eds. Johnson JE and Marshall PA. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority and Australian Greenhouse Office, Australia.
- Fabricius KE, De'ath G, Poutinen ML, Done T, Cooper TF, Burgess SC (2008) Disturbance gradients on inshore and offshore coral reefs caused by a severe tropical cyclone.Limnology and Oceanography 53: 690–704
- Fabricius KE, Mieog J, Idip D, Colin P, van Oppen M (2004) Identity and diversity of coral endosymbionts (zooxanthellae) from three Palauan reefs with contrasting bleaching, temperature and shading histories. Molecular Ecology 13: 2445–2458
- Marubini F, Ferrier-Pagès C, Furla P, Allemand D (2008) Coral calcification responds to seawater acidification: a working hypothesis towards a physiological mechanism. Coral Reefs 27: 491-499.Lough JM (2008) A changing climate for coral reefs. Journal of Environmental Monitoring 10: 21-29.
- Lough JM (2000) 1997-98: Unprecedented thermal stress to coral reefs?. Geophysical Research Letters 27: 3901-3904
- Lough JM (2011) Climate Change and Coral Reefs. Encyclopedia of Modern Coral Reefs – Structure, Form and Process, (David Hopley, Ed.), Springer. Dordrecht, pp. 198-210.
- Lough JM (2008). Shifting climate zones for Australia's tropical marine ecosystems. Geophysical Research Letters 35, L14708, doi: 10.1029/2008GL034634
- Fabricius K, C Langdon, S Uthicke, C Humphrey, S Noonan, G De'ath, R Okazaki, N Muehllehner, M Glas & JM Lough (2011). Winners and losers in coral reefs acclimatized to elevanted carbon dioxide concentrations. Nature Climate Change. Doi:10.1038/nclimate1122.
- Lough JM (2011). Great Barrier Reef coral luminescence reveals rainfall variability over northeastern Australia since the 17th century. Paleoceanography26doi:10.1029/2010PA002050.
Sweatman H, Delean S, Syms C (2011) Assessing loss of coral cover on Australia's Great Barrier Reef over two decades, with implications for longer term-trends. Coral Reefs 30:521-531
Osborne K, Dolman AM, Burgess SC, Johns KA (2011) Disturbance and dynamics of coral cover on the Great Barrier Reef (1995-2009). PLoS One 6:e17516